Difference between c sharp generics and Collections with example

Shailendra Chauhan

Print 4 min read

22 Aug 2022

Intermediate

367K Views

Generics provides the type-safe code with re-usability like an algorithm. In algorithms such as sorting, searching, comparing, etc. you don’t specify what data type(s) the algorithm operates on. The algorithm can be operated with any types of data. In the same way, Generics operate, you can provide different data type to Generics. For example, a sorting algorithm can operate on integer type, decimal type, string type, DateTime type, etc.

In this article, I will demonstrate the advantage of c sharp Generics over Collections. Following are the main advantage of Generics.

Code Re-usability with Generics

Suppose, you required to sort the integer and floating type numbers, then let's see how to do in collections and generics.

How to do it using Collections

//Overloaded sort methods
private int[] Sort(int[] inputArray)
{
//Sort array
//and return sorted array
return inputArray;
}
private float[] Sort(float[] inputArray)
{
//Sort array
//and return sorted array
return inputArray;
}

How to do it using Generics

private T[] Sort(T[] inputArray)
{
 //Sort array
 //and return sorted array
 return inputArray;
}

Here, T is short for Type and can be replaced with the Type defined in the C# language at runtime. So once we have this method, we can call it with different data types as follows and can see the beauty of Generics. In this way, Generics provide code re-usability.

Now if you thinking you can make fool to the compiler by passing an integer array while it is asking for a float, you are wrong. The compiler will show the error at compile time like as:

Type Safety with Generics

Suppose, you want to make a list of students, then let's see how to do in collections and generics.

How to do it using Collections

In collections we can use ArrayList to store a list of Student objects like as:

class Student
{
public int RollNo{get; set;}
public string Name{get; set;}
}

//List of students
ArrayList studentList = new ArrayList();
Student objStudent = new Student();
objStudent.Name = "Rajat";
objStudent.RollNo = 1;

studentList.Add(objStudent);

objStudent = new Student();
objStudent.Name = "Sam";
objStudent.RollNo = 2;

studentList.Add(objStudent);

foreach (Object s in studentList)
{
//Type-casting. If s is anything other than a student
Student currentStudent = (Student)s;
Console.WriteLine("Roll # " + currentStudent.RollNo + " " + currentStudent.Name);
}

Problem with Collections

Suppose by mistake you have added a string value to ArrayList like as

studentList.Add("Generics"); //Fooling the compiler

Since ArrayList is a loosely typed collection and it never ensures compile-time type checking. Hence the above statement will compile without error but it will throw an InvalidCastException at run time when you try to cast it to Student Type.

How to do it using Generics

In generics we can use generic List to store a list of Student objects like as:

List<Student> lstStudents = new List<Student>();

Student objStudent = new Student();
objStudent.Name = "Rajat";
objStudent.RollNo = 1;

lstStudents.Add(objStudent);

objStudent = new Student();
objStudent.Name = "Sam";
objStudent.RollNo = 2;

lstStudents.Add(objStudent);

//Looping through the list of students
foreach (Student currentSt in lstStudents)
{
//no need to type cast since compiler already knows that everything inside 
//this list is a Student
Console.WriteLine("Roll # " + currentSt.RollNo + " " + currentSt.Name);
}

Advantage with Generics

In case of collections, you can make fool to the compiler but in case of generics, you can't make fool to the compiler as shown below. Hence Generics provide Type Safety.

Cleaner Code with Generics

Since compiler enforces type safety with Generics. Hence fetching data from Generics don't require typecasting which means your code is clean and easier to write and maintain.

Better Performance with Generics

As you have seen in the above example, at the time of fetching the data from the ArrayList collection we need to do type casting which causes performance degrades. But at the time of fetching the data from the generic List, we don't require to do type casting. In this way, Generics provide better performance than collections.

What do you think?

I hope you will enjoy the tips while programming with C#. I would like to have feedback from my blog readers. Your valuable feedback, question, or comments about this article are always welcome.